Recruitment Challenges Easing for State and Local Governments, New Report Finds
July 23, 2024
After years of unprecedented workforce shortages, state and local governments are finally experiencing some relief in recruitment challenges. Key occupations, including information technology, dispatch, and policing, have seen a decline of at least ten percentage points since 2022 in the share of governments reporting these positions as hard to fill. However, a significant workforce issue still looms: the impending wave of public service worker retirements.
These findings are detailed in a new research report, State and Local Workforce: 2024 Survey Findings. Conducted annually since 2009 by MissionSquare Research Institute in collaboration with the Public Sector HR Association (PSHRA) and the National Association of State Personnel Executives (NASPE), this survey focuses on recruitment, retention, compensation, and staff development challenges faced by state and local governments.
Watch a video detailing the research findings.
“The data indicate that state and local governments are making real progress when it comes to addressing their workforce shortages,” said Gerald Young, MissionSquare Research Institute Senior Researcher. “Government employers have been experimenting with a range of initiatives that are getting results – marketing campaigns, hiring bonuses, pay boosts, and modifications to job requirements. The next challenge for state and local leaders will be ensuring they have ample workers as a large portion of the workforce retires from public service.”
Additional key survey findings are as follows:
- Anticipated Retirements: 54% of respondents expect the largest wave of retirements to occur in the next few years. To prepare, 32% have or are developing formal succession planning processes.
- Compensation: While 73% respondents consider their total compensation competitive, only 60% believe their wages are competitive. Approximately 53% have implemented broad-based pay increases in the past year.
- Staffing Trends: About 21% of governments report full-time staffing increases of 5% or more, while only 2% report decreases.
- Hiring Bonuses: Bonuses are offered broadly (4%) or in a targeted manner (33%), with 13% requiring repayment if an employee stays less than one year.
- Degree Requirements: More than half of the respondents have dropped some degree requirements, with 8% eliminating them for more than 10% of authorized positions.
“State and local leaders should be applauded for their tenacity when it comes to addressing the public workforce crisis,” said PSHRA CEO Cara Woodson Welch. “While challenges remain, agencies are making real progress attracting and keeping qualified workers to deliver essential public services through strategic human resources initiatives. PSHRA and its members will utilize these findings as we continue to implement pragmatic solutions that ensure a stable workforce citizens can rely upon.”
“It’s so encouraging that we’re seeing results from the thoughtful worker recruitment and retention strategies deployed by jurisdictions,” said NASPE Executive Director Leslie Scott Parker. “For example, efforts to modify job descriptions and degree requirements clearly are helping fill positions. It’s also clear that raising salaries is helping address the public worker shortage, which is increasingly important given the impending wave of retirements.”
The survey, conducted from March 8 through April 25, 2024, involved 300 state and local government human resource staff respondents.
About MissionSquare Research Institute
MissionSquare Research Institute promotes excellence in state and local government and other public service organizations to attract and retain talented employees. The organization identifies leading practices and conducts research on retirement plans, health and wellness benefits, workforce demographics and skill set needs, labor force development, and topics facing the not-for-profit industry and education sector. MissionSquare Research Institute brings together leaders and respected researchers. More information and access to research and publications are available here.
About MissionSquare Retirement
Since our founding in 1972, MissionSquare Retirement has been dedicated to simplifying the path to retirement security for public service employees. As a mission-based, nonstock, nonprofit financial services company, we manage and administer over $78.5 billion in assets.* Our commitment to delivering results-oriented retirement plans, education, investments, and personalized advice sets us apart. Explore how we enable public service workers to build a secure financial future. For more information, visit www.missionsq.org or follow the company on Facebook, LinkedIn, and X.
*As of June 30, 2024. Includes 457, 401, 403(b), Retirement Health Savings (RHS) plans, Employer Investment Program (EIP) plans, affiliated IRAs, and investment-only assets.